No one is an accidental expat. Anyone who leaves their home country – whether it's for reasons as carefree as wanting to taste adventure in far-off lands or as devastating as fleeing an oppressive dictator to save their lives – has to put a fair amount of willpower into it. It's not easy to leave the land where you first learned to speak, where your parents raised you, where you know the names of everything without having to ask someone. No matter where you go, you still came from somewhere, and that somewhere is your culture, your background, your point of reference, and no matter how many new passports you collect, it's still – in some way and in some small part – your Home.
So even though there's much I don't like about American culture, values, politics, and so on, and even though I've actively wanted to move out of the U.S. for most of my life, and even though I've always identified as a New Yorker and not an American, I can't deny that the U.S. is still where I come from, and it has a certain importance in my life that I'll never be able to expunge. And so the events of the past week have struck me with an indelible sadness, and shock, and most of all, shame. No one – no matter what their culture, values, or politics – should have to go through what the people of New Orleans and the Gulf Coast have been going through for the past number of days. How can the most powerful country in the world allow an entire city to fall beneath the waves and leave its poorest citizens to die on their rooftops? If you polled 9 out of 10 average Americans on where they'd rather live, the U.S. or Thailand, they'd all say, "America's the greatest country in the world – why would I want to live anywhere else?" And yet when the tsunami struck out of nowhere on a clear morning, the government of Thailand (and of Indonesia, Sri Lanka, etc.) sprang into action to help its people. They brought in people, they brought in trucks, they brought in elephants, for god's sake. The U.S. government, who had days of advance warning, dragged their collective feet and smiled for the cameras, insisting that everything was fine and help was on the way. But can they really say that to the face of the man whose mother, an elderly woman trapped in her nursing home, drowned after five days of waiting for someone to come and rescue her?
Sometimes I feel like I'm the only one staring up at the naked emperor and wondering why the hell no one else can see he's not wearing any clothes. And I want to shake everyone else by the shoulders and force them to see past the red-white-and-blue-colored blinders they've got on, because they don't deserve to live like this. No one does, not anywhere, and it's the least understandable when something like this happens in one of the richest nations on the globe, a country whose federal stationery budget could feed an entire developing nation, a country where the rich get massive tax cuts while the poor send their children off to die in foreign countries because at least in the military they'll get some health insurance.
I'm torn between feeling so glad not to be back there, and so sad that the people I love still are. Or that anyone has to be, really.
If you haven't already, please give some money to relief efforts.
Posted by wildsoda at September 5, 2005 07:37 PMWildsoda, you have put into words all the thoughts that have been buzzing through my head this past week in such an incredibly elegant and heartfelt way that I salute you. Thanks for writing such a brilliant post.
Posted by: kimbofo at September 7, 2005 09:40 PMThank you very much for the comment. It actually means quite a lot to me to hear you say that.
Posted by: wildsoda at September 8, 2005 03:10 AMHere's another perspective from someone outside of the USA (published in Irish Times Today). It's a different take on what's happening:
http://www.sluggerotoole.com/archives/2005/09/ill_wind_may_no.php
Posted by: Andy at September 9, 2005 01:54 PMBrilliant!
All I can say is that even here in Manhattan the devastation down South is a nightmare far more upsetting than 9/11 was.
And if it weren't for my wife, I'd emigrate in a heartbeat. This place just isn't safe any more.
By the way, Andy -- I'm not entirely sure of the relevance of the Irish Times article that you posted. That's a piece by a non-American writer living outside of the U.S. My piece is by an American expat living abroad. Not that he can't have an opinion, of course, but I don't see what relevance it has to my experience as posted on a blog about expat experiences.
Thank you for your post which is so strong... It must be hard to be far away from home, but it's good to share so difficult times.
Good luck for the rest of your stay.
Marion